Quantifying the effect of exercise on total energy expenditure in obese women
Colley, Rachel Christine (2007) Quantifying the effect of exercise on total energy expenditure in obese women. PhD thesis, Queensland University of Technology.
The prevalence of obesity continues to increase despite considerable research and innovation regarding treatment and management strategies. When completed as prescribed, exercise training is associated with numerous health benefits and predictable levels of weight loss. However, under free-living conditions the benefits of exercise are less consistent, suggesting that non-adherence and/or a compensatory response in non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT) may be occurring. The accurate quantification of all components of total energy expenditure (TEE), including TEE itself, was imperative to elucidate the primary research question relating to the impact of exercise on TEE. In addition, the measurement of changes in body composition and the response to prescribed exercise were assessed in methodological and pilot investigations. Following this extensive background, the primary research question relating to the effect of exercise on levels of TEE and the associated implications of such a compensatory response could be more rigorously investigated.
The first study investigated the variability in isotopic equilibrium time under field conditions, and the impact of this variability on estimates of total body water (TBW) and body composition when using the deuterium dilution technique. Following the collection of a fasting baseline urine sample, 10 women and 10 men were dosed with deuterium oxide (0.05g/kg body weight). Urine samples were collected every hour for 8 hours. The samples were analysed using isotope ratio mass spectrometry and time to equilibration was determined using three commonly employed data analysis approaches. Isotopic equilibrium was reached by 50, 80 and 100% of participants at 4, 6 and 8 h, respectively. The mean group equilibration times determined using the three different plateau determination methods were 4.8 ± 1.5, 3.8 ± 0.8, and 4.9 ±1.4 h, respectively. Isotopic enrichment, TBW, and percent body fat estimates differed between early sampling times (3-5 h), but not later sampling times (5-8 h). Therefore, sampling < 6 hours post dose compared to sampling ≥ 6 hours resulted in greater relative measurement error in TBW and body composition estimates. Although differences in equilibration time were apparent between the three plateau determination approaches, sampling at 6 hours or later may decrease the likelihood of error in body composition estimates resultant from incomplete isotopic equilibration in a small proportion of individuals.
In the second study, the aim was to measure the self-paced walking (SPW) speed of adults ranging in body size from normal to obese. The utility of heart rate monitors to estimate the energy cost of walking was also investigated. Twenty-nine participants (12 normal-weight, 17 overweight or obese) completed two outdoor walking tests to determine their SPW speed. A walking treadmill test with stages below, at, and above the SPW speed was completed to compare the energy expenditure estimates of the Polar S610 and WM42 heart rate monitors with that from indirect calorimetry. The average SPW speed was 1.7 ± 0.1 msec-1, which was equivalent to an exercise intensity of 48.6 ± 9.4 %VO2max (61.0 ± 7.1 %HRmax). There was no difference in the energy expenditure estimation between indirect calorimetry (4.7 ± 0.7 kcalkg-1h-1), the S610 (4.8 ± 1.3 kcalkg-1h-1) and the WM42 (4.8 ± 1.6 kcalkg-1h-1).
It was concluded that the heart rate monitors provided reasonable energy expenditure estimates at the group level. However considerable error was evident at the individual level, explained in part by exercise heart rate and fitness level, suggesting that an individualised calibration should be performed where possible. An additional finding from this study was that 145 to 215 minutes of SPW per week, dependent upon the level of adiposity, is required to meet the current American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) guidelines for health of 1000 kcal*wk-1.
The purpose of the third study was to establish the level of adherence to a specific exercise prescription (1500 kcalwk-1) by objectively quantifying unsupervised exercise energy expenditure (ExEE) in a group of obese women. The 16-wk lifestyle intervention consisted of weekly meetings with research staff, combined with promotion of increased ExEE (1500 kcalwk-1) and a decreased dietary intake (-500 kcald-1). Twenty-nine obese females (Body Mass Index = 36.8 ± 5.0 kgm2, Body Fat = 49.6 ± 3.7 %) from a hospital-based lifestyle intervention were included in the analysis. ExEE was estimated and monitored weekly using heart rate monitoring. Body composition was measured before and after the intervention by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA). Results indicated free-living adherence to the exercise prescription was modest and variable, with 14% of participants achieving the 1500 kcalwk-1. The average weekly ExEE (768 kcalwk-1) represented 51.2% of the total amount prescribed. ExEE was correlated with changes in body weight (r = 0.65, p < 0.001) and fat mass (r = 0.65, p = 0.0002). Achievement of a 5% weight loss target was dependent on an ExEE level of 1000 kcalwk-1 (p <0.001). Exercise 'adherers' (> 000 kcalwk-1) lost more weight (-9.9 vs. -4.1 kg), more fat mass (-6.8 vs. -3.0 kg), and more waist circumference (-9.8 vs. -5.6 cm) when compared to 'non-adherers' (< 1000 kcal*wk-1). The results suggest that the extent of supervision and monitoring influenced exercise adherence rates. The variability in adherence highlights the importance of objective monitoring of ExEE. Identification of individuals not complying with program targets may enable intervention staff to provide additional support or make individualised adjustments to the exercise prescription.
The fourth study investigated issues relating to the management and interpretation of
accelerometry data when the device is to be used to monitor levels of daily physical activity. Given the high between-individual variability in accelerometry output for a given walking speed, the use of a more individualised approach to the data management has been suggested. In addition, accelerometry was used to compare daily physical activity patterns between a supervised and unsupervised exercise prescription of the same dose (1500 kcalwk-1) in overweight and obese women. Total energy expenditure, activity energy expenditure, and vector magnitude increased significantly during the intervention. Time spent in very low intensity movement decreased from baseline to the intervention (p < 0.01) in both the supervised (-18.6 mind-1) and unsupervised (-68.5 mind-1) group, whereas time spent in high and vigorous intensity movement increased significantly from baseline to the intervention (p < 0.05 and p < 0.0001, respectively). The increase in vigorous movement was significantly greater in the supervised group when compared to the unsupervised group (+11.5 vs. +5.4 mind-1, p < 0.05). Time spent above three different moderate-intensity walking thresholds increased from baseline to the intervention (p < 0.0001). The threshold determination approach significantly affected the resultant outcomes (p < 0.0001) such that the standard threshold was significantly different to both group-specific and individualised approaches. Significant differences were also noted in accelerometer output between treadmill and overground walking (p < 0.0001). A positive finding of this study was that two different interventions aimed at increasing physical activity levels in a group of sedentary and obese women were successful in gaining modest increases in overall daily movement. The change observed appears to be a replacement of sedentary movement with more vigorous physical activity. Collectively, the differences observed between threshold determination approaches, as well as between treadmill and overground walking, highlight the need for standardised approaches to accelerometry data management and analysis. In addition, the findings suggest that obese women may benefit from a certain degree of exercise supervision to ensure compliance, however, strategies to encourage these women to continue with the exercise on their own without supervision are essential to making a sustainable long-term change to their lifestyles.
The final study aimed to assess whether obese women compensate for structured exercise by decreasing their NEAT and thereby impeding weight loss. Thirteen participants were prescribed 1500 kcal*wk-1 of exercise through a structured walking program (4 week supervised followed by 4 weeks unsupervised). The energy expenditure of the walks was quantified using individually-calibrated Polar F4 heart rate monitors. The DLW technique was used to measure TEE. Accelerometry measures were also collected throughout and represented an alternative method of quantifying changes in total daily movement patterns resultant from an increase in energy expenditure through exercise. Compliance with the exercise program was excellent, with the average compliance being 94% over the 8-week intervention. The adoption of moderate-intensity exercise in this group of obese women resulted in a 12% decrease in TEE (p = 0.01) and a 67% decrease in NEAT (p < 0.05). No significant change was observed in resting metabolic rate from baseline to the postintervention time-point. Compensation was significantly correlated with dietary report bias (r= -0.84, p = 0.001), body image (r = 0.75, p < 0.01), and bodily pain (r = -0.65, p < 0.05). A linear regression model including dietary reporting bias and the pain score explained 78% of the variation in ΔTEE. Compensators were therefore less likely to underreport their dietary intake, less likely to be self-aware of their obese state, and more likely to be experiencing pain in their daily life. Self-reported dietary intake decreased significantly during the intervention (p = 0.01) with specific decreases noted in fat and carbohydrate intake. The consequence of compensation was evidenced by a lack of significant change in body weight, body composition, or blood lipids (p > 0.05). However, positive outcomes of the study included improvement in the SF-36 scores of general health (p < 0.05) and maintenance of exercise program adherence into the unsupervised phase of the intervention. Qualitative data collected via interview indicated that 85% of participants experienced increased energy and positive feedback from peers during the intervention. This study confirms that exercise prescription needs to be prescribed with an individualised approach that takes into account level of adiposity. The goal of exercise prescription for the obese should therefore be to determine the intensity and modality of exercise that does not activate compensatory behaviours, as this may in turn negate the beneficial effects of the additional energy expenditure of exercise.
This study confirms that during the initial phase of an exercise-based weight loss intervention, the majority of obese women compensated for some, if not all, the energy cost of the exercise sessions by reducing NEAT. Whether this compensatory behaviour continues beyond the first month of an exercise program, particularly after training adaptations in cardiorespiratory fitness are realised, cannot be discerned from the current study. However these results do provide a rationale for why the magnitude of weight loss achieved is often less than predicted during exercise interventions. Further research is required to examine the temporal pattern of compensation in NEAT, and the relationship between the time courses of NEAT compensation relative to physical fitness improvements. The results from this thesis support the use of activity monitors such as accelerometers during weight loss interventions to track NEAT and provide objective feedback regarding compensatory behaviours to clinicians and the obese individuals.
Impact and interest:
Citation counts are sourced monthly from and citation databases.
These databases contain citations from different subsets of available publications and different time periods and thus the citation count from each is usually different. Some works are not in either database and no count is displayed. Scopus includes citations from articles published in 1996 onwards, and Web of Science® generally from 1980 onwards.
Citations counts from theindexing service can be viewed at the linked Google Scholar™ search.
Full-text downloads displays the total number of times this work’s files (e.g., a PDF) have been downloaded from QUT ePrints as well as the number of downloads in the previous 365 days. The count includes downloads for all files if a work has more than one.
|Item Type:||QUT Thesis (PhD)|
|Supervisor:||Byrne, Nuala & Hills, Andrew|
|Keywords:||physical activity, exercise energy expenditure, non-exercise activity thermogenesis, NEAT, exercise adherence, body composition, accelerometry, heart rate monitoring, deuterium dilution, lifestyle interventions|
|Divisions:||Current > QUT Faculties and Divisions > Faculty of Health
Current > Schools > School of Exercise & Nutrition Sciences
|Department:||Faculty of Health|
|Institution:||Queensland University of Technology|
|Copyright Owner:||Copyright Rachel Christine Colley|
|Deposited On:||03 Dec 2008 04:05|
|Last Modified:||15 Apr 2015 04:28|
Repository Staff Only: item control page